Agenda and minutes

Venue: Hendon Town Hall, The Burroughs, London NW4 4BQ

Contact: Paul Frost - 0208 359 2205  Email:

No. Item


Minutes of last meeting pdf icon PDF 64 KB


    The Chairman welcomed those in attendance and in particular Councillor Hellene Richman as it was her first meeting.


    The Chairman noted that a matter raised at the last meeting in respect to a scheme member not receiving a pension due in an administering error had been rectified.    Members noted that no impact to an individual had been caused. 


    Resolved that the minutes of the meeting held on 11 February 2019 be approved as a correct record.



Disclosable Pecuniary interests and Non Pecuniary interests




Absence of Members


    An apology of absence was received from Councillor Thomas.  Councillor Richman was therefore in attendance as a substitute Member.  


Public Question and Comments (if any)




Report of the Monitoring Officer (if any)




Members' Items (if any) pdf icon PDF 193 KB


    Mr Sala Rida was given the opportunity to introduce his Members Items.  He requested that Board Members give consideration to the item and requested support for his Member’s item.  He also noted that that policy should be made available and be reviewed regularly.  The Chairman requested that Council Officer Mr George Bruce provide Members with a verbal response.  In doing so he said that he would provide an update to Members when possible via email.



    Having considered the Member’s Item the Local Pensions Board:




    -          noted the Member’s item

    -          noted the verbal response

    -          request that Officers circulate the policy

    -          requested that a report be added to the work programme to report the policy to the meeting.



Pension Fund External Audit Plan for the year ended 31 March 2019 pdf icon PDF 213 KB

    Additional documents:


    Mr George Bruce introduced the item.  He outlined the information in Appendix A that illustrated the audit plan for 2018/19.  The Board members were given the opportunity to comment.   In doing so questions were asked  which Officers duly responded to.



    That the Local Pension Board noted the audit strategy for the 2018/19 Report

    and Accounts.



Pension Committee Decisions pdf icon PDF 225 KB


    The Chairman introduced the report.  He informed the Board that he personally attended the last meeting of the Pension Fund Committee.  He also reminded Board Members that he has continued to have regular dialog with the Pension Fund Committee Chairman.    He invited Mr George Bruce to make further comment which he duly did.   Mr Bruce gave an overview of the reports received by the Pension Fund Committee and that had been determined. 


    During the discussion, Mr Hem Savla requested that Board Members be invited to all training, this was agreed. 




    -          That the Local Pension Board notes the procedures applied by the Pension Fund Committee when reaching decisions at recent meetings and considers any issues associated with those procedures and decisions. The outcome of these discussions to be reported back to the Pension Fund Committee.

    -          That the Board requested to be invited to all training events



Data Quality Update pdf icon PDF 208 KB

    Additional documents:


    The Chairman invited Capita representative, Mr Mike Green to give an account of the report and to field questions from Board Members.   Mr Green said that he and Capita colleagues had been working with the Council in order to improve the quality of data.   


    Mr Savla outlined his concerns on the condition of the data and requested that a report be produced that outlined preventive measures that provided reassurance to Board Members as to the future integrity of relevant pension-related data.   Mr Green said that a review meeting would take place with Council Officers and he stated that the outcome of that meeting would be reported accordingly.


    Mr Rida sought clarity of how the data will be improved and requested to know how work will be continued in order for the valuation to reach a satisfactory level.   This was noted.


    Mr Woodcock said that with respect to missing data it would be an advantage if the submission of data should delayed  until all relevant informed has been submitted. 


    The Chairman said he wanted to understand why employers apparently cannot fill out a form successfully and submit it.   Mr Hopkins outlined that the process administered by Capital had been revised and an escalation point had been established that resulted in self reporting and penalties to employers.   Mr Hopkins said that he hoped levying’ financial penalties would not take place but he added it was an option.


    The Chairman concluded that he would update the Chairman of the Pensions Fund Committee with respect to this report.



    The Board are asked to note the content of the Data Cleanse Summary (Appendix A).



Risk Register pdf icon PDF 222 KB

    Additional documents:


    Mr Gareth Hopkins, Pensions Consultant for Barnet, introduced the report and gave a summary, noting the risk register documented in appendix A.  He said that following the last meeting he had added 3 further risks as a result of working in consultation with Board Member Mr Stephen Ross.


    Mr Savla stated that the London Borough of Barnet were the only local government client of Capita.  He suggested that all other local government bodies had opted for an alternative administrating authority and he stated that the Capita relationship was therefore was a risk.    The Director of Finance, Mrs Anisa Darr stated that eh Environment Agency were also a  client of the Capita.  She also stated that she had reassurance that Capita had the expertise and resources to deliver a Local Government Pension Service as the administering authority for the London Borough of Barnet.  


    Mr Rida noted that the late submission of data was a key risk and he added that this was of immediate concern. 



    -          Risked and noted

    -          Thanks, was given to Mr Ross for his work on the risk register




Performance Report pdf icon PDF 204 KB

    Additional documents:


    The Chairman invited Capita representative, Mr Mike Green to give an account of the report.  Mr Woodcock made a statement surrounding the quality of data outlining that the data already exists in the schemes and therefore he believed there was a strong need for better housekeeping and data monitoring.


    Mr Green said that over time there had been a change of requirements for data and therefore it can be difficult for smaller employers to submit and control data.


    Mr Savla requested to know if there was any consistency to the reasons why the quality of data is so poor across the board.     He said that in some respects it was unacceptable.     Mr Green said that he was to hold a ‘lesson-learnt’ meeting with Council Officers.  He noted that smaller employers had independent payroll teams.   He said that he would report back to the Local Pension Board on this matter.    He added that Capita had full control of the administrating arrangements and that work is being undertaken to reduce the number of outstanding issues



    The Local Pension Board noted the performance levels.



Board Work programme pdf icon PDF 159 KB



    That the Local Pensions Board noted the Work Programme and requested the inclusion of the following reports:


    The Local Pensions Annual Report

    A Training update and report


    The Local Pension Board further requested that individual training plans be recalculated.



Any other exempt item(s) the Chairman decides are urgent